(JollofNews) – I hereby ask Chief Servant Adama Barrow to ask his Attorney General Aboubacarr Tambadou to immediately withdraw the case against Fatou Badgie charged for insulting the president. Such a move would not only demonstrate exemplary leadership and commitment to the change we yearned for, but it will also go further to weakening adversaries and agents provocateur who wish to subvert the peace and stability of the Gambia. If Barrow goes ahead to withdraw this case, it will also serve to heal the nation, promote reconciliation and console the losers, which are his responsibilities as he is the president of all Gambians. It is high time we are magnanimous.
Having said that, let me state it very categorically that to insult a public officer in essence is not an offence within the broader context of democracy. Citizens have a right to express unpleasant words against their government and public officers to show their disagreement. That is basic. This is not to say we must encourage profanities in our society, but we cannot also punish it by arresting citizens for using profane words. While it is true that every society has culture, which has its norms and values, yet in matters of public affairs we cannot use culture and religion to determine how citizens engage with public institutions, public officers and public policy.
Insult laws however do exist in many countries including the Gambia characterized as sedition. In our Criminal Code under Section 51, sedition or seditious intention is, among others things when a person utters words that bring hatred, contempt or disaffection against the person of the president. Furthermore in 2013 an amendment to the Information and Communication Act created the offence of ‘false news’ when a person is said to spread false information against the government or public officers thus liable for 15 years jail term or a fine of 3 million dalasi!
We must bear in mind that in the first place sedition laws are colonial weapons intended to limit the ability of our people to resist colonialism and seek freedom. After gaining independence several African countries still maintain this obnoxious law and only replaced the Queen with President to reflect the new nation. In his 22 bloody years, Yaya Jammeh and APRC have effectively used this colonial law to limit the ability of the Gambians to hold them to account. We can all recall the many court cases against innocent citizens for merely saying paste the picture of the president on the sky. One can see that even in the Information and Communication Act, the attempt is merely to limit the space and freedoms just to entrench the APRC Tyranny.
In light of the foregoing, when we decided on December 1, we had decided not just for a regime change but also more importantly for a system change. Hence never again should we have sedition in our laws. The crime of ‘false news’ in the Information and Communication Act as well as the ‘false news publication’ and ‘giving false information to a public officer’, which are all in our Criminal Code, must be expunged. These are anti-democratic laws intended to terrorize citizens when they exercise their constitutional rights.
In their manifesto, one of the topmost priorities of the Coalition is to review our constitution and laws to ensure that such bad provisions are removed so that we have human rights-friendly and democratic laws. For that matter, it is necessary that Barrow start the implementation of that objective in practice by asking his Attorney General Aboubacarr Tambadou to withdraw this case against Fatou Badgie. The lady has a right to express her opinion and it may not be pleasant. If she had said that Barrow was a good and handsome man, I am sure no one would arrest her. Why then should she say the opposite and she got arrested?
We expect that the Minister of Justice, Aboubacarr Tambadou would provide the most honest advice to the president to understand what is sensible and useful legally and what is not. If Tambadou fails to do his job, I wish to urge Magistrate Bah overseeing this case to throw it out. There is no merit in this case other than to damage Section 25 of our constitution on the right to free expression, which is an entrenched clause.
We can all recall a similar incident in Ghana during the tenure of the late Pres. John Atta Mills when an opposition sympathizer insulted him in 2010. After the police arrested the man, Pres. Mills asked the charges be dropped for the man to go free. In the US, we also recall how a congressman Joe Wilson called Pres. Obama a liar as he delivered his state of the union address in 2009. Yet Obama never pursued the matter and the man was never arrested. But in both cases, friends and colleagues of both insulters rebuked them for their profanity. But the law did not do anything and those societies are only getting better. Hence a friend or family member of Fatou Badgie could reprimand her, but it is utterly undemocratic and a threat to national security if Fatou Badgie continues to be prosecuted and sent to jail. Let us protect our democracy!
Gambians, let us bear in mind that for 50 years, since independence we could not build a modern democratic state. This is now our opportunity to do so in order to fundamentally transform our lives for the better. In this task, not everything will be, as we like. But let us remember that we are not governing our society based on the Bible or the Quran or based on our traditional beliefs. We are building a new Gambia based on our constitution and laws. Thus we must stop seeing public officers and the government in terms of our culture and religion. Hence the way we relate with our kabilo head or imam or priest is not the same way we should respond to our president, mayor or minister. They hold different positions. Let us understand those differences so that we do not make the president a kabilo head or an imam or priest. That would be a national disaster as we have witnessed since independence.
Free Fatou Badgie Now.
God Bless the Gambia.
Absolutely Madi. It’s asinine to think such a thing can happen so quick after all we went through with Yahya. That innocent woman Fatou Badgie must be released immediately with apologies and compensation. She stands firmly on solid grounds to insult any official she deemed incompetent. If The President does not like what she said, then he should go to court and sue her for libel using his own salary for legal cost. Gambians have a right to free speech and expression. Will the police arrest her if she insult me? No. Does Barrow have more rights than any other Gambian just because he is a civil servant? No. This is a disturbing trend that must stop. Arresting Fatou Badgie is a crime and abuse of power. President Barrow must address this incident publicly, release her immediately and promise or reassure Gambians that such unlawful act will never happen again. Allah forbid a Yahya reincarnation.
Madi, Dr Sarr and I have made similar arguments for the release of Fatou Badjie and have urged others to make similar calls. Your article have buttress our points. We should take president Barrow and the Justice Minister out of the equation and instead put pressure on the Director of Public Prosecution to drop the charges against Fatou Badjie. I don’t want to encourage politicians to interfere with judicial matters. Let us give public officials a confidence boost by encouraging and supporting them to freely exercise the functions of their posts. If the DPP did not drop the charges then we should mount a campaign to put pressure on the magistrate to throw the case out with prejudice. We have to stand up and be counted for defending every Gambian’s right to freely express themselves, especially the freedom of expression of those whose views we disagree with and to defend democracy in the Gambia. All human rights are important, we must never cherry pick which rights to defend and which to abuse.
Who would have actually made the arrest and laid any charge? Is that at all clear?
Miranda who ever made the arrest and charges should have used their brains before doing so. If they had they would have realised that it won’t be in public interest to charge and remand her for using few choice word against the president. The resources been used to pursue this case could be best used to prevent violent crime. All what we demand now is the release of the poor woman to reunite with her children.
Buba how can we reach the DPP to make him understand the need to drop charges and release her. Perhaps if we have his email address or tel#, we can flood him with our pleas.
I know there would be some followers the online media who have the DPP’s contact and those people will bring to his attention people’s displeasure with this incident. Also president Barrow had said they used to follow the online media a lot so am guessing that his intelligence service will continue to follow online media and include the hot topics in their intelligence brief. As part of the reforms underway, we must demand that all public departments and parastatals have contact emails and number for use by the general public.
I just hope that Madi Joberteh is not advocating that its better to be living in Anarchy , or Anarchism. Sometimes self contradictory, as reading through his articles prompt me to assume…….could there be another reason to be coming so hard on the norms of our society; respect to the elders or their repsesentatives.I do not know how old is the insulting lady but it is unlikely that she is older than the Gambian President.
Anything in excess even praying…..this is a moment for the Gambian people to reflect on the values of our cultures. There are no written codes of these cultures but reasoning and guidiance by the holy scripts or Laws by legislators. Without adherence to them the siuation would have been out of control during the past political impass. Yet still it is not late for tribalism to raise its ugly head and hijack our humanly endeavours to live in peace and harmony.